Tips for debugging your new programming language August 11, 2021 on Drew DeVault's blog

Say you’re building a new (compiled) programming language from scratch. You’ll inevitably have to debug programs written in it, and worse, many of these problems will lead you into deep magic, as you uncover problems with your compiler or runtime. And as you find yourself diving into the arcane arts, your tools may be painfully lacking: how do you debug code written in a language for which debuggers and other tooling simply has not been written yet?

In the implementation of my own programming language, I have faced this problem many times, and developed, by necessity, some skills around debugging with crippled tools that may lack an awareness of your language. Of course, the ultimate goal is to build out first-class debugging support, but we must have a language in the first place before we can write tools to debug it. If you find yourself in this situation, here are my recommendations.

First, I’ll echo the timeless words of Brian Kernighan:

The most effective debugging tool is still careful thought, coupled with judiciously placed print statements.

— Unix for Beginners (1979)

Classic debugging techniques are of heightened importance in this environment: first seek to isolate the problem code, then to understand the problem code, then form, and test, a hypothesis — usually with a thoughtful print statement. Often, this is enough.

Unfortunately, you may have to fire up gdb. gdb is often painful in the best of situations, but if you have to use it without debug symbols, you may find yourself shutting off the computer and seeking out rural real estate on which you can establish a new career in farming. If you can stomach it, I can offer some advice.

First, you’re going to be working in assembly, so make sure you’re familiar with how it works. I would recommend keeping the ISA manual and your ABI specification handy. If you’re smart and your language sets up stack frames properly (this is easy, do it early), you should at least have a backtrace, breakpoints at functions, and globals, though all of these will be untyped. You can write C casts to add some ad-hoc types to examine data in your process, like “print *(int *)$rdi”.

You’ll also get used to the ‘x’ command, which eXamines memory. The command format is “x/NT”, where N is the number of objects, and T is the object type: w for word (int), g for giantword (long), and h and b for halfword (short) and byte, respectively: “x/8g $rdi” will interpret rdi as an address where 8 longs are stored and print them out in hexadecimal. Of particular use is the “i” format, for “instruction”, which will disassemble from the given address:

(gdb) x/8i $rip
=> 0x5555555565c8 <rt.memcpy+4>:	mov    $0x0,%eax
   0x5555555565cd <rt.memcpy+9>:	cmp    %rdx,%rax
   0x5555555565d0 <rt.memcpy+12>:	jae    0x5555555565df <rt.memcpy+27>
   0x5555555565d2 <rt.memcpy+14>:	movzbl (%rsi,%rax,1),%ecx
   0x5555555565d6 <rt.memcpy+18>:	mov    %cl,(%rdi,%rax,1)
   0x5555555565d9 <rt.memcpy+21>:	add    $0x1,%rax
   0x5555555565dd <rt.memcpy+25>:	jmp    0x5555555565cd <rt.memcpy+9>
   0x5555555565df <rt.memcpy+27>:	leave  

You can set breakpoints on the addresses you find here (e.g. “b *0x5555555565d0”), and step through one instruction at a time with the “si” command.

I also tend to do some silly workarounds to avoid having to read too much assembly. If I want to set a breakpoint in some specific place, I might do the following:

fn _break() void = void;

export fn main() void = {
    // ...some code...

    // Point of interest
    let x = y[z * q];

    // ...some code...

Then I can instruct gdb to “b _break” to break when this function is called, use “finish” to step out of the call frame, and I’ve arrived at the point of interest without having to rely on line numbers being available in my binary.

Overall, this is a fairly miserable process which can take 5-10× longer than normal debugging, but with these tips you should at least find your problems solvable. Good motivation to develop better debugging tools for your new language, eh? A future blog post might go over some of this with DWARF and possibly how to teach gdb to understand a new language natively. In the meantime, good luck!

Have a comment on one of my posts? Start a discussion in my public inbox by sending an email to ~sircmpwn/ [mailing list etiquette]

Articles from blogs I read Generated by openring

Status update, May 2022

Hi all! This month’s status update will be shorter than usual, because I’ve taken some time off to visit Napoli. Discovering the city and the surrounding region was great! Of course the main reason to visit is to taste true Neapolitan pizza. I must admit, th…

via emersion May 24, 2022

What's cooking on SourceHut? May 2022

Hello everyone! We’re back at it for another month of news in the SourceHut sphere. Of our now 29,036 users, 630 are new this month: please offer them a warm welcome, and your patience, as they learn about the new platform. Comprehensive GraphQL-na…

via Blogs on Sourcehut May 16, 2022

Summary of changes for April

Hey everyone! This is the list of all the changes we've done to our projects and apps during the month of April. We'll also be reporting in our on position in the world, and on our future plans. Summary Of Changes Bicycle, released an Uxntal pla…

via Hundred Rabbits May 1, 2022