Gmail is a huge source of spam February 25, 2021 on Drew DeVault's blog

5× as many spam registrations on sourcehut are from gmail than from the second-largest offender.

# SELECT
  SPLIT_PART(email, '@', 2) as domain, count(*) as count
  FROM "user"
  WHERE user_type = 'suspended'
  GROUP BY domain
  ORDER BY count DESC;
          domain           | count
---------------------------+-------
 gmail.com                 |   119
 qq.com                    |    26
 mail.ru                   |    17
 mailinator.com            |    10
 yopmail.com               |     6
 aol.com                   |     6
 yahoo.com                 |     6
[...more omitted...]

This is just the ones which got through: most spam registrations are detected and ignored before they make it to the database.

A huge number of spam emails I recieve in my personal inbox originate from @gmail.com, and often they arrive in my inbox unscathed (as opposed to going to Junk) because Gmail is considered a reputable mail provider. My colleague estimates that between 15% and 25% of the spam emails sent to a mailing list he administrates comes from Gmail.

One might argue that, because Gmail is the world’s largest email provider, it’s natural to expect that they would have the largest volume of spam simply because they have proportionally more users who might use it for spam. I would argue that this instead tells us that they have the largest responsibility to curtail spam on their platform.

I’ve forwarded many, many reports to abuse@gmail.com, but they’ve never followed up and the problem has not become any better. I have had half a mind to block Gmail registrations on sourcehut outright, but about 41% of all registrations use Gmail.

It bears repeating that anyone with any level of technical expertise ought to know better than to use Gmail. I usually recommend Migadu1, but there are many options to choose from. If you’re worried about mail deliverability issues, don’t be — it’s more or less a myth in $CURRENTYEAR. If you set up DKIM properly and unlist your IP address from the DNSBLs (a simple process), then your mails will get through.

In case you’re wondering, the dis-award for second-worst goes to Amazon SES. They don’t register on sourcehut (it’s outgoing only, so that makes sense), but I see them often in my personal inbox. However, SES only appears at a rate of about a tenth of the gmail spam, and they appear to actually listen to my abuse reports, so I can more or less forgive them for it.


  1. Full disclosure: sourcehut has a business relationship with Migadu, though I’ve recommended them since long before we met. ↩︎

⇒ This article is also available on gemini.

Have a comment on one of my posts? Start a discussion in my public inbox by sending an email to ~sircmpwn/public-inbox@lists.sr.ht [mailing list etiquette]

Articles from blogs I read Generated by openring

Site Redesign

Hey y’all! It’s been, gosh, what, ten years? I finally finished a total site redesign: all-new backend, HTML, CSS, modern image formats, etc. It’s finally readable on mobile now! There’s a lot of accumulated cruft in the database and filesystem–aphyr.com i…

via Aphyr: Posts March 28, 2021

What's cooking on SourceHut? March 2021

Hi! Another month of development has passed, and I’m here to fill you in on what’s new. Another 686 signups this month has brought us to 21,041 users. As always, I’ll be counting on you to make the new users feel at home, please be patient with them and help…

via Blogs on Sourcehut March 15, 2021

Status update, March 2021

Hi all! This month has been a little bit more quiet than others. I’ve spent a fair bit of time working on gamescope for Valve. As usual I’ve been fixing bugs and improving gamescope itself, but I’ve also worked on the rest of the ecosystem. I’m plumbing forma…

via emersion March 15, 2021