Fostering a culture that values stability and reliability January 4, 2021 on Drew DeVault's blog

There’s an idea which encounters a bizarre level of resistance from the broader software community: that software can be completed. This resistance manifests in several forms, perhaps the most common being the notion that a git repository which doesn’t receive many commits is abandoned or less worthwhile. For my part, I consider software that aims to be completed to be more worthwhile most of the time.

There are two sources of change which projects are affected by: external and internal. An internal source of change is, for example, a planned feature, or a discovered bug. External sources of change are, say, when a dependency makes a breaking change and your software has to be updated accordingly. Some projects will necessarily have an indefinite source of external change to consider, often as part of their value proposition. youtube-dl will always evolve to add new sites and workarounds, wlroots will continue to grow to take advantage of new graphics and input hardware features, and so on.

Any maintained program will naturally increase in stability over time as bug fixes accumulate, towards some finite maximum. However, change drives this trend in reverse. Introducing new features, coping with external change factors, even fixing bugs, all of this often introduce new problems. If you want to produce software which is reliable, robust, and stable, then managing change is an essential requirement.

To this end, software projects can, and often should, draw a finish line. Or, if not a finish line, a curve for gradually backing off on feature introduction, raising the threshold of importance by which a new feature is considered.

Sway, for instance, was “completed” some time ago. We stopped accepting most major feature requests, preferring only to implement changes which were made necessary by external sources: notably, features implemented in i3, the project sway aimed to replace. The i3 project announced this week that it was adopting a similar policy regarding new features, and thus sway’s change management is again reduced in scope to only addressing bugs and performance. Sway has completed its value proposition, and now our only goal is to become more and more stable and reliable at delivering it.

scdoc is another project which has met its stated goals. Its primary external source of change is roff — which is almost 50 years old. Therefore, it has accumulated mainly bugfixes and robustness over the past few years since its release, and users enjoy a great deal of reliability and stability from it. Becoming a tool which “just works” and can be depended on without a second thought is the only goal going forward.

Next time you see a git repo which is only getting a slow trickle of commits, don’t necessarily write it off as abandoned. A slow trickle of commits is the ultimate fate of software which aims to be stable and reliable. And, as a maintainer of your own projects, remember that turning a critical eye to new feature requests, and evaluating their cost in terms of complexity and stability, is another responsibility that your users are depending on you for.

⇒ This article is also available on gemini.

Have a comment on one of my posts? Start a discussion in my public inbox by sending an email to ~sircmpwn/ [mailing list etiquette]

Articles from blogs I read Generated by openring

Status update, May 2022

Hi all! This month’s status update will be shorter than usual, because I’ve taken some time off to visit Napoli. Discovering the city and the surrounding region was great! Of course the main reason to visit is to taste true Neapolitan pizza. I must admit, th…

via emersion May 24, 2022

What's cooking on SourceHut? May 2022

Hello everyone! We’re back at it for another month of news in the SourceHut sphere. Of our now 29,036 users, 630 are new this month: please offer them a warm welcome, and your patience, as they learn about the new platform. Comprehensive GraphQL-na…

via Blogs on Sourcehut May 16, 2022

Summary of changes for April

Hey everyone! This is the list of all the changes we've done to our projects and apps during the month of April. We'll also be reporting in our on position in the world, and on our future plans. Summary Of Changes Bicycle, released an Uxntal pla…

via Hundred Rabbits May 1, 2022